RAIRI Case Studies – Brazil and Indonesia
Key Takeaways
- Even when dealing with complicated supply chains, firms must remain diligent about tracking environmental harm or risk serious reputational impacts.
- Degrees of separation existing between a company and its suppliers or subsidiaries does not insulate companies from stakeholder backlash.
- Moving forward, companies should consider not only their sustainability commitments, but more importantly their implementation strategies.
Deforestation is a global issue affecting not only global warming and local ecosystems, but also local communities. Indigenous groups that rely on forests for sustenance and cultural heritage are being displaced en masse as their territories are cleared for farming, mining, and other industrial activities. Though Indigenous communities are often protected by laws in the countries they reside in, this isn’t always the case — and even when legal frameworks exist, it is not uncommon for companies and suppliers to ignore them. With over 10 million hectares of forests cut down annually across the world, pressure on multinational businesses to avoid deforestation in their supply chains is mounting.[1] This is compounded by increasing scrutiny from environmental advocates for companies’ commitments and follow-through.
Environmental impacts in company supply chains can be difficult to track, posing both risk to the firm and a potential opportunity to obscure damage. In the cases below, we examine several companies that overlooked illegal deforestation by their suppliers, impacting fragile rainforest ecosystems and local communities in both South America and Southeast Asia. These cases are unique in that they focus on large agribusiness corporations with complex, layered production chains, placing them far from the harm being done — but not from the reputational harms that followed. We then attempt to quantify those harms using the Rebecca Adamson Indigenous Rights Index (RAIRI). For more information about the index, and it’s methodology, see Wharton Impact’s introductory blog post here.

BMW and Brazil – How Car Manufacturers Affect the Amazon
In 2020, over 1 million hectares of Brazilian rainforest were destroyed, largely driven by the cattle raising industry.[2] Most of the Amazon is protected by law from deforestation, making land clearing for agriculture largely illegal. Reports from around that year revealed that cattle from farms engaging in illegal deforestation, land grabbing, and human rights violations in the Amazon had entered the supply chains of Brazil’s major leather manufacturers.[3] 80% of Brazilian leather is exported, much of which supplies the global automotive industry — linking several large car brands to illegal deforestation.[4]
These companies’ current supply chain monitoring systems typically only look at the actions of farms that directly supply slaughterhouses, overlooking farms that are leveraging intermediaries to cover up the illegal raising of their cattle — a practice known as cattle laundering.[2, 4] Lear corporation, the world’s leading car seat manufacturer who sources most of its leather from Brazil, is a major supplier for both BMW and Volkswagen.[4] A series of investigative reports by nonprofit groups revealed illegal deforestation in both companies’ supply chains, which coincided with a significant drop in their RAIRI scores. Volkswagen, for example, fell within the top 3% of lowest-scoring named entities in Brazil in 2020, the year following the release of supply chain research by NGO Global Canopy.
However, despite backlash from the reports, these firms were not quick to accept blame. Volkswagen responded by reiterating its requirement for suppliers to source leather “responsibly,” though the company admitted to lacking complete traceability throughout its supply chain. BMW said it had strict sustainability requirements in place for leather suppliers alongside annual audits, adding that it was developing tools to better monitor its supply chain.[5] Following these claims, their scores recovered; but their statements proved to be insufficient to guard against media criticism. In 2022 and 2024, the Environmental Investigation Agency released reports that again linked the companies’ suppliers to illegal deforestation for cattle raising, including on the Apyterewa Indigenous territory in the Brazilian Amazon.[4, 6] They were criticized for being “unwilling” to take action to remove deforestation from their supply chains, causing their reputational scores to again drop to negative.
Michelin and Indonesia – Joint Ventures Landgrab in Summatra
A similar story took place around the same time in Indonesia involving the largest tire manufacturer in the world, Michelin. In a 2015 joint initiative with rubber plantation company PT Royal Lestari Utama (RLU) and energy company Barito Pacific, Michelin launched its flagship “sustainable” rubber project in Sumatra. The companies raised $95 million in sustainable bonds to finance the initiative, describing plans to replant trees, conserve wildlife, and provide jobs to local community members — commitments that they still claim to uphold to this day.[7, 8] However, a 2020 report revealed that Michelin may have covered up industrial-scale deforestation of over 2,500 hectares of Indonesian rainforest by its subsidiaries. Reports alleged that the illegal logging — primarily carried out by RLU subsidiary Lestari Asri Jaya (LAJ) — continued even after Michelin agreed to the joint initiative.[9] The affected rainforests are home to two Indigenous communities, the Talang Mamak and the Orang Rimba, and also serve as a wildlife habitat for several endangered species.[10]
In 2021 interviews with Tempo magazine, Indigenous residents of the area said that they initially resisted the RLU partnership offer for fear of losing the right to freely use their land, but were ultimately forced by the company — aided by local police — to comply.[7] These claims align with a documented history of land grabbing by LAJ. A number of local news reports and statements documented LAJ’s “violent disputes, clashes, evictions and land conflicts with villagers and Indigenous peoples” associated with its deforestation activities in the Jambi province. Villagers further alleged that they had not been consulted nor given consent prior to the deforestation, and one researcher found that many villagers did not know about the Michelin joint initiative at all.[9] Michelin was further implicated in this controversy when it became the sole owner of RLU in 2022, tying it closely to the harmful actions of RLU’s subsidiaries.[11]
A 2-year investigation by Voxeurop following this report revealed that Michelin had known about the deforestation plans prior to the start of the project, and rather than taking action, they continued to market it as a sustainable venture to help attract green bond investors. According to the investigation, more unconventional funding methods were necessary because traditional banks had refused to finance the project, likely having discovered the deforestation and land grabbing that occurred during the pre-establishment phase of the project.[11] Michelin’s actions directly conflict with its sustainability policy, which pledges to use only natural rubber that has been produced in accordance with “zero deforestation” principles.[12] In 2020, the year that the major report was released, Michelin’s media sentiment score on Indigenous themes in Indonesia had shifted from positive to negative, dropping by over 250%.
Companies Can Work To Repair Their Reputations
These examples indicate that when companies are found to be complicit in environmental or Indigenous land use violations, even when not directly, their reputations suffer. In terms of how to recover, the right solution may be taking accountability. In December 2024, BMW released its formal anti-deforestation policy, outlining concrete risk mitigation strategies and plans to enhance supply chain traceability.[13] The following year, its RAIRI score rebounded from negative to positive, placing it in the top 8% of highest-scoring named entities in Brazil in 2025, indicating positive media sentiment towards the company. This case suggests that prioritizing transparency and actionable solutions allows firms to begin rebuilding their image.
So, what should companies be taking away from this? Even when dealing with complicated supply chains, firms must remain diligent about tracking environmental harm or risk serious reputational impacts. Degrees of separation existing between a company and its suppliers or subsidiaries does not make a link to industrial-scale deforestation any less incriminating, especially given the investigative bandwidth of environmental nonprofits and independent news outlets today. Stakeholders care about these issues even if the firm is a few levels-removed. Moving forward, companies should consider not only their sustainability commitments, but more importantly their implementation strategies.
For more information about Brazil and Indonesia, see country files for each on the webpage.
References
- Ritchie, H. (2021, February). Deforestation and forest loss. Our World in Data. https://ourworldindata.org/deforestation
- New Report: How the European car industry drives rainforest destruction. (n.d.). Regnskogfondet. https://www.regnskog.no/en/news/silk-bidrar-bilindustrien-til-avskoging-i-amazonas
- Deforestation in the Driver’s Seat – EIA. (2025, July 10). EIA. https://eia.ornews.mongabay.com/…/companies-sourcing-beef-leather-from-china-exposed-to-brazil-deforestation-risk-researchers-sayg/report/deforestation-drivers-seat/
- Leather car seats linked to illegal Amazon forest destruction. (2022, December 17). Eia.org. https://eia.org/press-releases/leather-car-seats-linked-to-illegal-amazon-forest-destruction/
- Mongabay. (2019, August 27). Companies sourcing beef, leather from China exposed to Brazil deforestation risk, researchers say (Daniel, Ed.). Conservation News. http://news.mongabay.com/2019/08/companies-sourcing-beef-leather-from-china-exposed-to-brazil-deforestation-risk-researchers-say/
- EIA’s investigations into illegal cattle ranching in the Brazilian Amazon hit German TV – EIA. (2024, May 3). EIA. https://eia.org/blog/eia-investigation-into-illegal-cattle-ranching-hit-german-tv/
- Valentino, S. (2024, May 30). Analysis: Michelin’s no-deforestation claims in Indonesia rubber plantation a stretch. Mongabay Environmental News. https://news.mongabay.com/2024/05/analysis-michelins-no-deforestation-claims-in-indonesia-rubber-plantation-a-stretch/
- RLU Natural Rubber | Michelin. (2015). Michelin.com. https://natural-rubber.michelin.com/natural-rubber-by-michelin/history/royal-lestari-utama
- Wijeratna, A. (2020). COMPLICIT AN INVESTIGATION INTO DEFORESTATION AT MICHELIN’S ROYAL LESTARI UTAMA PROJECT IN SUMATRA, INDONESIA. https://www.mightyearth.org/wp-content/uploads/Mighty_Earth_MichelinReport8Oct2020FINAL.pdf
- Jones, S., & Mitchell, C. (2023, November 30). Report: Michelin Covered Up Industrial Deforestation by its Indonesian Partner in “Eco-Friendly” Rubber Venture – Mighty Earth. Mighty Earth. https://mightyearth.org/article/report-michelin-covered-up-industrial-deforestation-by-its-indonesian-partner-in-eco-friendly-rubber-venture/
- Valentino, S., & Barbiroglio, E. (2022, November 9). European green finance is paying for deforestation in Indonesia: the case of Michelin – VoxEurop. Https://Voxeurop.eu/En/. https://voxeurop.eu/en/greenwashing-european-green-finance-paying-deforestation-indonesia-case-michelin/
- MICHELIN SUSTAINABLE NATURAL RUBBER POLICY REFERENCE DOCUMENT -2021 Edition > SUSTAINABLE NATURAL RUBBER POLICY. (2021). https://purchasing.michelin.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/04/Michelin-Sustainable-Natural-Rubber-Policy_2021_v1.3_EN.pdf
- The BMW Group. (2024, December). BMW Group Anti-Deforestation Policy. Bayerische Motoren Werke . https://www.bmwgroup.com/content/dam/grpw/websites/bmwgroup_com/responsibility/downloads/en/2024/202412_BMW_AntiDeforestationPolicy_EN.pdf
